wood floors

...now browsing by tag

 
 

Comparing Hardwood Flooring vs Laminate Flooring

Thursday, July 29th, 2010

Continuing on our adventure with the White Kitchen Redesign project, here and here, my client Lorraine and I decided our next step would be to begin to look at flooring.

lorraine4

 

She knew she wanted to get rid of the old linoleum (thank goodness), and she also knew she wanted wood floors which would be continued from the entryway in through the kitchen. But of course, she did not want to spend a lot of money.  I had heard good things about the new laminate flooring, so I researched the wood/laminate options and this is what I found:

  Prefinished Engineered
Hardwood Floor
Laminate Floor
Visual Appearance excellent good
Scratch Resistance good4 very good
Stain Resistance fair1 excellent
Fade Resistance fair2 excellent
Impact Resistance good excellent
Ease of Maintenance good very good
Moisture Resistance fair good
Ease of Repair good poor
Can floor be refinished? yes (not acrylic impregnated) no
Install over concrete slab if glue or float yes, floating
Manufacturer’s Warranty good good
Installation Methods glue, staple, float some pre-glued
glueless, floating
Easy To Install (DIY) glueless floating – yes
staple-down – maybe
glue-down – messy
Yes
Life expectancy of floor (in years) 25+3 < 20
  1. some hardwood flooring factory finishes have very good stain resistance
  2. some wood stains when exposed to direct UV sunlight may change color more than others
  3. Quality hardwood floors can last for a lifetime with proper care & refinishing
  4. Some UV-cured urethane finishes have aluminum oxide crystals embedded in the finish and are extremely durable

Resource- Floor Facts.com

 Bruce Engineered Oak Hardwood Flooring Strip and Plank                                                                                                          

 

 

 

 

 

 

Can you tell the difference?  Natural Oak Laminate is on the left.  Solid Oak Hardwood is on the right.

One important factor they left off of this comparison chart- price.  I checked quite a few sources and found the same results- hardwood flooring is two to three times more expensive. 

James Radin

James Radin

So what did Lorraine decide on?  She is planning to sell her home in about five years so she is trying to get the home ready for resale. Plus, a big factor in her decision was pricing.  She decided she would go with the laminate flooring, in a medium finish which will work well with her existing furnishings as well as her new cabinets and new counter tops.  It will look beautiful!   Comments?  Questions?  Advice?

If you need help with your decorating dilemma, call 401.765.7999, or write me @ kellybernierdesigns.com

Share on Facebook
Home & Garden Blogs - Blog Rankings Home & Garden Blogs
home-garden blog sites Home & Garden Blogs
Home & Garden blogs